15 Replies  3296 Views  Last Post: 10 June 2013  05:14 PM
#1
Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  09:45 PM
I was assuming Trig, but figured I'd ask.
"Both" is out of the question for reasons that would take too long to explain.
Replies To: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
#2
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  09:48 PM
Edit: To add though, Trig has very little depth, so you could easily selfstudy. College Algebra might round you out more.
#3
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  09:58 PM
Quote
The description for Trig is:
Quote
So I assume Trig then?
edit: I'm too unmotivated for selfstudy. I need an obligation (going to class) to get anything done.
This post has been edited by Yatta!: 09 June 2013  09:59 PM
#4
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:01 PM
#5
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:04 PM
Yatta!, on 09 June 2013  11:45 PM, said:
Nevertheless, it's the best answer. Or rather, "both and more, or either, or neither, depending on what you want to do".
If you have neither, I suppose mac's right and trig is the more important one, but I don't see a case where either of them alone buys you a lot. What do you want math for? As a programmer, you might want to be able to do certain calculations for modeling for example, locations on a screen, distances and veocities of objects in the world you're building, that sort of thing. That requires trig, but if you're going to be making use of that information you're probably going to want a lot more math on top of it. I can't imagine you being in a situation where trig is useful and a lack of calculus is not crippling. Or, if you want to get into depth on the algorithms you use, you're going to be using whole different branches of math  discrete math will be the name of the course you'll take for that. This is the "both, and more" case.
Or, you might want to be able to think mathematically about the world. In that case, either will be useful, and they will help you to think in more useful ways about the world. This is the "either" case  it doesn't advance you professionally, but that doesn't mean it should be ignored.
Or, if you just want to write programs and make use of libraries, and you don't really care to think mathematically about what you're doing, you can skip most of the math  people have written the libraries that figure out what you need, and you don't have to think about it. This is the "neither" case. For me, it's the wrong answer, but it seems to work for a lot of people, many of whom get paid more than I do, so what the hell do I know?
#6
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:06 PM
#7
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:21 PM
I've been sitting 2.5 units away from completing my 2 year degree for the last 3 or 4 years. To put that into perspective a bit, Trig is worth 3 units and College Algebra is worth 4. I've been getting pestered (and rightfully so) to get my last class over with these last few years. I think I've finally worked the motivation up, so I wanted to take one math course. Don't get me wrong, I actually like math (not enough to sit still during selfstudy), but I DESPISE school. I'm the ultra antisocial type, so everything about school feels like it works against me. So I just want to take the one class, get the eff out of Dodge, and move on with life.
From the looks of what people are posting, Trig is probably what I'm going to go for.
This post has been edited by Yatta!: 09 June 2013  10:24 PM
#8
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:29 PM
Really...
if you're taking these remedial level math courses in college just to get a degree... flip a coin.
Trig or Algebra?
In the grand scheme of things they don't mean shit to you. Personally i'd say both and a shit ton more, but you obviously want nothing to do with a any mathematical education, so who cares. Flip the coin.
#9
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:29 PM
Quote
I don't mean selfstudy in the formal coursework sense. But if you're developing a game and say "hey, I need to know how to deal with vector equations," then you can look up enough trig to get by and that's about the same amount of trig you'd get in class.
With subjects like Calculus, you may not develop the same intuition as well as in a more formal classroom setting.
#10
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 09 June 2013  10:44 PM
lordofduct, on 09 June 2013  11:29 PM, said:
Really...
if you're taking these remedial level math courses in college just to get a degree... flip a coin.
Trig or Algebra?
In the grand scheme of things they don't mean shit to you. Personally i'd say both and a shit ton more, but you obviously want nothing to do with a any mathematical education, so who cares. Flip the coin.
If I'm going to be paying money to take one of these math courses, I want the most bang for my buck in regards to what I want the knowledge for. Is that really too much to ask?
I probably overreacted here. When I feel aggression from someone, even aggression that might have not been there, I tend to get aggressive back in kind. I think my antisocial is showing.
macosxnerd101, on 09 June 2013  11:29 PM, said:
With subjects like Calculus, you may not develop the same intuition as well as in a more formal classroom setting.
Ah, I see. I guess I'll take some more time to consider which I'll take, then.
This post has been edited by Yatta!: 09 June 2013  11:07 PM
#11
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 10 June 2013  06:50 AM
EVERYONE should take Algebra and Trig.
I'm blown away that both aren't required courses for your degree. The school I went to required them for 90% of the degrees... the only ones not requiring it were some odd arts degrees.
If in the end you really want to make a measured comparison for 'bang for buck'. Take the College Algebra. Algebra is just something everyone should have a firm grasp on. As was stated earlier, Trig is rather shallow. A lot of places combine trig with other stuff because it's so shallow. i.e. Precalculus & Trig, if this class is available, take it... though Algebra probably is a prereq. This is what I'm wondering... what math have you taken? Did you skip over continuous all together and focus on discrete and statistics?
#12
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 10 June 2013  06:54 AM
Quote
Quote
Not to be rude, but in all seriousness, you might consider some sort of counseling. We all have to work with people at some point beyond the internet. It doesn't pay to be miserable about it.
#13
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 10 June 2013  04:21 PM
lordofduct, on 10 June 2013  07:50 AM, said:
If in the end you really want to make a measured comparison for 'bang for buck'. Take the College Algebra. Algebra is just something everyone should have a firm grasp on. As was stated earlier, Trig is rather shallow. A lot of places combine trig with other stuff because it's so shallow. i.e. Precalculus & Trig, if this class is available, take it... though Algebra probably is a prereq. This is what I'm wondering... what math have you taken? Did you skip over continuous all together and focus on discrete and statistics?
The way I understood it, to get a two year degree, I needed to pick between one of three math courses: Trig, College Algebra, or Finite. I took Finite, which is the highest level math course I've taken (though it was easier than Algebra2 imo...). They pretty much handed me a piece of paper with multiple sections, each section with multiple courses. Within each section, it said "take X amount of units using the courses listed here". I did all that but I haven't taken 60 units total, yet.
As for Precalc & Trig, my school only offers them separately, and to take Precalc, I have to take Trig first. Maybe they dig a little deeper with Precalc at my school or something, though. It's worth a whole 5 units.
macosxnerd101, on 10 June 2013  07:54 AM, said:
Done that. Went to a Psychologist twice and a Psychiatrist twice. More nerve wracking than my first job. Wasn't worth it in my book.
P.S. Does this website hate my ISP or something? Takes like 10 tries just to get into a thread because I fail to connect.
This post has been edited by Yatta!: 10 June 2013  04:37 PM
#14
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 10 June 2013  04:36 PM
Yatta!, on 10 June 2013  06:21 PM, said:
This website hates everybody's ISP. If you get a good connection take a look at the threads in the Site Support forum... it'll make you cry.
For the math, I'd suggest you take what you need for your degree, and then pursue the rest on your own. Calculus, obviously, is important for a lot of disciplines, so you'll want to work your way up to that, but you might want to think about some of the more abstract areas as well. Number theory and set theory, boolean algebra, are all good fun, and Dover has good and cheap books that you can puzzle over. The Euler Project will give you a lot of practical exposure to some pure math. And you can probably find a course in Discrete Math on Coursera if you're into that.
If you don't want to pay a school, and you don't like being in classes, just find another way to do it, is my advice.
#15
Re: Would Trig or College Algebra be more helpful for a programmer?
Posted 10 June 2013  05:02 PM
