[Creecher]

GWatt, on 29 July 2011 - 02:27 PM, said:

@NeverPool

Spoiler

Wasn't Jaime at the dinner Joffrey choked? I thought it was earlier than that.
Tyrion actually poisoned Joffrey

Hmm

Spoiler

I can't really remember if Jaime was there or not, I'd like to say it was where he was during his captivity, but I can't be sure.

[fromTheSprawl]

Spoiler

Tyrion didn't poison Joffrey! Get your facts straight!

Anyway finished the TV Series! WTF? Renly and Loras? ''

[GWatt]

@fromTheSprawl:

Spoiler

finish a storm of swords. And if you can't wait, flip to the last bit. On my book it's somewhere about 1066.

[fromTheSprawl]

I've finished all four books! What made you think:

Spoiler

Tyrion did it? It was just the suspicion of the masses because he poured the wine for Joffrey, plus he's not that stupid!

Lol what do you think?

[GWatt]

I think I'll take a quote from that book

Spoiler

"You poor stupid blind crippled fool. Must I spell every little thing out for you? Very well. Cersei is a lying whore, she's been fucking Lancel ans Osmund Kettleback and probably Moon Boy for all I know. And I am the monster they all say I am. Yes, I killed your vile son."
Tyrion to Jaime

So, I think Tyrion killed Joff because Tyrion said he did. I believe it's also touched upon later on in A Dance With Dragons.

[fromTheSprawl]

I think the sarcasm is lost on you?

Spoiler

He said that because he's mad at Jaime because Jaime's still blind to what Cersei has been doing, and he said he killed the son as an extension to the "Jaime believes everything Cersei says" thing such as saying that Tyrion killed Joffrey.

Unless she really ****ed Moon Boy. Where in the book?

This post has been edited by fromTheSprawl: 31 August 2011 - 01:56 AM

[Creecher]

Spoiler

She didn't really do Moon Boy, that part really was Tyrion's infamous sarcasm. She was doing the other guy, though (who was her cousin if I remember.)

[NeoTifa]

ffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu I'm still reading A Clash Of Kings.

[GWatt]

@fromTheSprawl

Spoiler

Tyrion is always sarcastic. However, the part where Tyrion comes out and says "I killed Joff" did not strike me as overly sarcastic. Especially not in the way that sarcasm is used to say one thing but convey a different meaning.

[fromTheSprawl]

Spoiler

She did it with Osmund Kettleback and Lancel Lannister, her cousin.

GWatt

Spoiler

I hate to use links, but read this link:

http://awoiaf.wester...yrion_Lannister

And I Google'd, folks agree, though it could be that majority of the things there are written by people like me.

NeoTifa stop opening the spoiler tags!

Anyone else want to share their thoughts on our debate?

Spoiler

Did Tyrion kill Joffrey?(No spoilers from A Dance With Dragons please!)

[fromTheSprawl]

Where did my ASOIF friends go? Anyway:

[Creecher]

I finally crashed and rebought the books the other day, I got 1-3 because I didn't have enough for the entire set and I'm not going to get the last one until it gets printed in paperback.

Currently 1/4th the way through the first book.

[BetaWar]

Just thought I'd drop in with a quick update.
Becasue of this thread I have...
... read the entire Mistborn series (and got my father and sister hooked on it)
... watched the Game of Thrones HBO series
... bought Game of Thrones and Clash of Kings (books) and started reading them

[Creecher]

You guys should check out the Bloodheir trilogy, amazing books.

[Magixion]

Is there sex?